Thursday, 8 December 2011

Be careful of what Lib Dems wish for

Alarm bells should be ringing in Swansea at the suggestion by Peter Black that the Welsh government should mimic Nick Clegg's "revolutionary” proposals to let councils to go into debt to fund tram schemes.

Notwithstanding the freebie episode, which saw council leader Chris Holley face an internal investigation after normal commissioning procedures were circumvented, the costs of these schemes are horrendous and their outcomes often uncertain.

One obvious example is the hugely controversial scheme undertaken by Edinburgh Trams Limited, a company wholly owned by the City of Edinburgh Council. Originally costed at £375 million in 2003, the budget was later increased to £545 million; in May 2011, it was revealed that £440 million had already been spent on the project.

Dogged by contractual disputes between contractors and project management company, the tram system has been scaled down dramatically from its original form. A series of start-stop-start decisions by the local authority that led to legal arguments eventually forced the Scottish Government to intervene.

Lib Dem-run Swansea Council has a track record for underestimating the cost of projects with an eventual doubling of spending that dates back to its rebuild of the city’s leisure centre. The idea that they could be allowed to borrow against future business rate income – and plunge the city further into debt – really does not bear thinking about.

5 Comments:

Anonymous said...

I had quite forgotten your revelation about Holley's political connections to the firm that did the free work. I am surprised that this backdoor arrangement didn't end up being reported to the Ombudmans as well.

Peter Black said...

I made no suggestion whatsoever that Swansea should borrow to fund a tram scheme. As it happens it is Labour Ministers who are proposing that Swansea and other Councils borrow more. The point of a TIF scheme is that it is targetted borrowing for regeneration purposes and is repaid from increased business rates on such development.

Anonymous said...

Quite a few people reported Chris Holley to the Ombudsman about the "freebie feasability report", however the Ombudsman in his 'wisdom' [I am being facetious] decided there was no case to investigate.

Swansea will not prosper until we get rid of the Lib dems locally and Peter Black in Cardiff - the idiots have already brought Swansea to its knees and made us a laughing stock. Roll on 2012 local elections.

Ceiliog said...

Last of the bendy buses in London tonight.

Shambo said...

Additional borrowing for councils is not the answer. The treasury will simply reduce the local government allocation by the same amount with no net benefit other than a whopping debt to be financed. A local income tax and a hands-off government at Westminster is long overdue .