Wednesday, 28 October 2009

Is anything else on offer other than bigger stilts?

It was interesting to read an item among all the otherwise expert analysis that it is possible to look at the referendum predictions from the YouGov poll from a different perspective and arrive at a further conclusion from the obvious one that the result will be tight. Despite claims published in the Western Mail that “42% of the Welsh electorate would vote Yes in a referendum on law-making powers for the Assembly”, the truth is that no-one is actually sure if that kind of percentage turnout is in any way achievable.

Whilst additional powers are naturally considered crucial among the political villagers of Cardiff Bay, pro-devolutionary forces - and their opponents – may have problems in convincing the tax-paying public that constitutional reform should also figure among their own priorities of employment, house prices and the cost of living.

Perhaps what we need are a few practical examples of how Wales - rather than the Welsh political establishment – would benefit. There is plenty of scope although we would probably not see control & construction of social housing returned to democratic local government control. It is unlikely that anyone will even talk about reversing the transfers. Waste management will probably remain under 'arms-length' control whilst economic development will stay a centralised under-resourced strategic function. Privatised utilities & services would stay that way and bankers would continue to get their bonuses.

Like we said, perhaps we need a few practical examples ....

4 Comments:

Draig said...

OK, a practical example. We could start with devolving energy consents to the Assembly, but for some curious reason, the Assembly seems very reluctant to call for this.

Wales is a net exporter of electricity, yet we are awash with new projects. There are all sorts of social and environmental impacts from these projects and they tend to be highly controversial with impacted communities.

The Welsh Assembly's energy policy is a mess. It sets targets for renewable generation, yet takes no account in the fact that a massive ramp-up in fossil fuel generation is taking place in Wales. Consents for these projects still lies with London, and although negotations for the transfer of these powers has been underway for at least 6 years, no progress has been made. Why?

Inverted said...

We can put you down as a NO then?

Rebekah said...

Not at all. We (or at least one of us) would just prefer to have something relevant to contemporary Wales and not the usual party political pissing contest.

Merfyn said...

Do you want examples or just a time machine?